Hi there,
Our TikTok feeds are serving whiplash this week. On one side: Olivia Dean’s The Man I Need, a rally cry set to the montage of men who are finally showing up, finally softening, finally meeting women where they are. On the other: Sabrina Carpenter’s Nobody’s Son, fueling a wave of videos about men who disappeared, disappointed, or destroyed confidence on their way out.
It’s two pop songs, but it feels like the entire cultural moment: half of us clinging to proof that good guys exist, half of us quietly grieving that most of them aren’t the ones we date.
So what does it mean when your For You Page is split between “he’s everything” and “he’s nothing”?
Let’s get into it.
– Team Necterine
THE FEED DOESN’T LIE
Two songs, one story
When a trend takes over TikTok, it’s rarely just about the song. It’s about the way it taps something raw in the culture.
Sabrina Carpenter’s Nobody’s Son is basically a chorus of collective trauma. The lyrics aren’t just sad-girl pop; they’re a mirror of how many of us feel: unchosen, unseen, disposable. Pair that with thousands of videos captioned with our most recent breakup stories and you’ve got an anthem for ghosting fatigue.
Meanwhile, Olivia Dean’s The Man I Need is gaining traction for the exact opposite reason. It’s hope set to melody. Clips of boyfriends cooking, partners showing tenderness, dudes holding babies — a curated feed of men being soft, kind, steady. Proof that the bar isn’t on the floor.
CULTURE CHECK
Why both resonate
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: both songs are true. Men can be the ones we need. And men do fail spectacularly. The reason these trends hit so hard is because most of us are living in the tension between the two.
We want proof. The good-guy montage reassures us that it’s possible.
We want solidarity. The heartbreak edits reassure us we’re not alone.
It’s not pessimism vs optimism. It’s two sides of the same dating coin — swiping between disappointment and desire, caught in the middle of a system that never taught us how to connect better.
FOR EVERYONE
Not just men, not just women
Yes, Nobody’s Son calls out men. Yes, Man I Need lifts them up. But zoom out: these songs resonate because we’ve all felt unseen, unsupported, or let down by someone we trusted.
Men are terrified of rejection. Women are exhausted by carrying the emotional weight. Queer folks navigate micro-communities where everyone’s dated everyone. Straight, gay, bi, nonbinary — nobody escapes the ache of wanting to be chosen and supported for who they are.
So this isn’t just a gender story. It’s a human one.
Which side of TikTok is hitting harder right now?
WHERE WE GO FROM HERE
Love isn’t dead, it’s undertrained
Good men (read: partners) aren’t unicorns. But they also don’t just appear because we wish harder. What we’re really craving — what both trends are screaming for — is a system that raises, encourages, and rewards emotional maturity. A dating culture where we are taught to communicate, taught to set standards, and all sides are actually supported in learning how to love well.
Maybe the answer isn’t sulking in our corners, but actually learning.
Learning to talk about needs without waiting until we explode.
Learning to support instead of silently testing.
Learning that rejection isn’t fatal, it’s practice.
That’s what Man I Need really is: not a perfect person, but someone who’s willing to learn with you.
That’s why we’re building Necterine. Not to replace hope, but to make it practical. To help you stop swiping between extremes and start building the connections you deserve — in real life, with real skills, not just another song on your feed.
CLOSING NOTE
The soundtrack is shifting
We don’t have to stay stuck between abandonment ballads and fantasy partners. The future of love — whoever you are, whoever you love — looks like relationships where we practice being the partner we want to find. Messy, imperfect, still showing up.
If your FYP is serving heartbreak and hope in equal measure, you’re not broken. You’re just in the thick of it, like the rest of us. Keep the standards, keep the softness, and remember: the songs might loop, but your story doesn’t have to.
xoxo,
Team Necterine
Know anyone who could use this newsletter? Let them know they can sign up here.
Dating sucks, but it doesn’t have to.
Necterine is a next-generation connection app to help you cultivate relationships.
Our mission is to redefine connection by celebrating every interaction. We provide tools and experiences that empower our users to discover themselves through the spectrum of relationships, from fleeting encounters to lifelong partnerships.